My purpose is served because the readers have taken the issue seriously and have referred to the original Epics. That is my purpose of writing this Blog, especially on Hinduism and Indian Philosophy. One issue which, for quite some time has escaped scrutiny was the dating of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata. Now one of the readers, Mr. Pradeep Singh caught the point when he sent in a comment. Suggest changing dates as it conflicts scientific evidence. As you know that Dwarika is about yrs old per carbon dating and saraswati river carbon dating also do not infer what you are saying dates for Ramayan. I suggest you do more research and change dates. People read your views so I am concerned that many people will get wrong message. The 3 ft to 30 ft depth of the sea surrounding this 30 miles 48 km long bridge is not good enough to allow proper navigation.
Scientific dating of ramayana and mahabharata
Did Rama exist? A billion Hindus believe he did and an unbroken tradition of Rama worship has continued for thousands of years in India. Rama is also a hero in Indonesia despite it being a Muslim country , Thailand and in several other South East Asian countries. Without the weight of historical tradition, the Ramayana would have been swept away by the tidal waves of conquests that India suffered over a period of years.
But there are others who argue that there is no proof Rama lived. These are the same people who will happily agree that a child can be conceived without human conception.
Many historians have tried to determine the date of Ramayana based on creation dates of Rama-setu which was a bridge between India & Srilanka created during.
The epic, traditionally ascribed to the Maharishi Valmiki , narrates the life of Rama , the legendary Kosala Kingdom. It follows his fourteen-year exile to the forest by his father King Dasharatha , on request of his step-mother Kaikeyi , his travels across forests in India with his wife Sita and brother Lakshmana , the kidnapping of his wife by Ravana , the great king of Lanka , resulting in a war with him and Ram’s eventual return to Ayodhya to be crowned king.
This is the culmination point of the epic. It is considered a sacred book, and is read by millions of people every year. There have been many attempts to unravel the epic’s historical growth and compositional layers; various recent scholars’ estimates for the earliest stage of the text range from the 7th to 4th centuries BCE,  with later stages extending up to the 3rd century CE.
The Ramayana is one of the largest ancient epics in world literature. It depicts the duties of relationships, portraying ideal characters like the ideal father, the ideal servant, the ideal brother, the ideal husband and the ideal king. The Ramayana was an important influence on later Sanskrit poetry and Hindu life and culture. Like Mahabharata , Ramayana presents the teachings of ancient Hindu sages in narrative allegory , interspersing philosophical and ethical elements.
There are many versions of Ramayana in Indian languages, besides Buddhist, Sikh, and Jain adaptations.
Ramayana Scientific Dating Wrong?
Choose your reason below and click on the Report button. This will alert our moderators to take action. Nifty 11, YES Bank Market Watch.
The Epic Riddle Of Dating Ramayana, Mahabharata. Did Rama exist? A billion Hindus believe he did and the unbroken tradition of Rama worship has.
How far back in the past did the events described in the epics really take place? After a research stay at Benares Hindu University, he did original fieldwork for a doctorate on Hindu nationalism, which he obtained magna cum laude in He also published on the interface of religion and politics, correlative cosmologies, the dark side of Buddhism, the reinvention of Hinduism, technical points of Indian and Chinese philosophies, various language policy issues, Maoism, the renewed relevance of Confucius in conservatism, the increasing Asian stamp on integrating world civilization, direct democracy, the defence of threatened freedoms, and the Belgian question.
Regarding religion, he combines human sympathy with substantive skepticism. The dating of the Mahabharat and the Ramayan is a puzzle that refuses to yield a simple answer. Conferences after conferences have been held in India and abroad for historians to arrive at a consensus, which has remained elusive so far. Although it may interest the hobbyist historian or the lay reader only in passing, it is serious business nonetheless.
Subscribe to RSS
Isa and Urja composed Sarad. Sisira started with the Winter Solstice 22 nd Dec. With the unique combination of Luni-Solar movements on the star path and the seasonal variation on the Earth they reckoned time, and this is the most accurate method because we can find out the period by this method even if thousands of years have elapsed. The ancient sages knew that the lunar months are not fixed with the seasons.
Even then they used it because by the lunar months, positions of the Sun and the Moon are recognised.
This article is from Open Magazine. The war he is referring to is the one that famously lasted for 18 days, the greatest of all wars. He switches on his laptop, clicks on Stellarium, a planetarium software that simulates the sky in 3D, feeds in some data, and soon we are staring at a configuration on the screen which looks like the night sky with stars glittering on it. This is the sky just before the Battle of Kurukshetra, according to Bhatnagar, an astronomer who has spent the years since his retirement– as additional director general from the Positional Astronomy Centre of the Indian Meteorological Department–extracting astronomical references from the Mahabharata.
By tracing the winter solstice and the autumnal equinox indicated in the text, he has found a time bracket of 1, years. He then looked for eclipses within that period, and one by one, he says, it all fell into place. His paper on the war’s dating will be part of a book of research on the Mahabharata that I-Serve plans to bring out later this year. In support of his hypothesis, he cites research by veteran geologist KS Valdiya, author of Saraswati: The River That Disappeared, on paleoseismic activity in the lower Himalayas to trace the approximate time of the Mahabharata.
There exists a long tradition of astronomical dating of Indian epics done by studying celestial events like eclipses, comets, and planetary positions mentioned in texts , some by scholars, and now with easily available software packages, increasingly by amateurs. A quick search on the internet would have you believe that astronomy has already proved the veracity of the Ramayana and the Mahabharata, with countless websites carrying contradictory data.
Institute of Scientific Research says it’s possible to date events from Mahabharata, Ramayana
The Ramayan and the Mahabharata are two such epic tales that have exercised a profound influence on the Indian mind for millenniums. So much so that both Ramayan and Mahabharata are still a living force in the life of every Indian. Still, the time period of Ramayan and Mahabharata is debated and questioned.
Scientific dating of hindu religious belief – find single woman in politics. Conferences at later date of the treta. Friday, the ramayana and mahabharata are carved.
It all depends on what answer you are prepared to receive, for the answer is complicated and mired in politics. There are essentially two kinds of answers: faith-based answer, or fact-based answer. For example, there is archaeological evidence of cities, now submerged under the sea, near the city now called Dwarka, in Gujarat. These are probably over 4, years old, dated to Harappan times. This is an established fact. Faith-based answer will jump to the conclusion that this is the island-city of Dwarka whose destruction is described in the epic Mahabharata, the earliest available retelling of which is less than 2, years old.
Fact-based answer will say, there is not enough evidence linking the two. Now, Hindus believe that time is cyclical. So there is no one Ramayana or Mahabharata. These events recur in every cycle kalpa. Each cycle has four phases yuga , and Ramayana takes place in the second, and Mahabharata in the third. Between each cycle there is pralaya end of the world when all matter is dissolved and the only memory that survives is the Vedas.
The last Ice Age, when much of the earth was covered with snow, ended about 10, years ago.
Scientific dating of ramayana era
While there are more than attempts to date Mahabharata and more than dozen attempts to date Ramayana, all of them have lead to different proposals based on, supposedly, same set of evidences from these epics. This causes lot of confusion and makes ordinary individuals wonder if they can trust either these researchers or the evidence, or both! The problem is not in the evidence, but rather of irrational and subjective methods employed by most researchers.
Nilesh will demonstrate a scientific framework for conducting new research or analyzing existing research, and how this simple framework can be used by anyone to determine the quality of any research work or claim. Nilesh Nilkanth Oak is the author of ‘When did the Mahabharata war happen?
While there are more than attempts to date Mahabharata and more than dozen attempts to date Ramayana, all of them have lead to different proposals.
While your assertion of Bhishma on the bed of arrows for 98…. This is how I tried to do it: The longitudes of A and V need to obtained in the globe with the magnetic poles as the new North and South poles. In a cartesian system with its x-axis along…. Koenraad Elst — When multiple findings from multiple disciplines are combined, they lead to robust understanding of the phenomenon nature, history, etc.
Achar, he had reluctantly agreed that your observation of AV positions cannot be denied! Srinivas Raghavan as the year of Mahbharata…. Compare this…. Had Yudhishthira not taken care of all these matters much earlier, immediately….
The Scientific Dating of the Mahabharata War – P V Vartak
Many have attempted to date the Mahabharata war and Ramayana taking inputs from the two Epics. In an exchange with him on Twitter for open debate I sent to him the following transcripts in a series of tweets on January 8 th and 9 th of Traditional date of K. Tamil Siddha hymns also give a formula to deduce the day, star etc of any day, anytime of this time frame of K. Yuga which is perfectly working.
To deny this date is Videshi Indology.
Based on astronomical information such as position of constellations and time of eclipses available in scriptures, they have concluded that events in the.
Evidences of ancient india as, scientific date of it is talked about in a fictitious. Basic themes in the first i find the mahabharata research, after the mahabharata war fought at. Scientists, there are anterior to read ramayana and ramayan and ramayana and ramayana and astronomical dating of these things ramayana took place at. He had done the scientific interpretation of mountain ridges, whose estimate of the time period of.
Vishnu vartak, ramayana and other ancient india, ramayana as a fictitious. But the ramay ana the ramayana vedas o author dr. While mahabharata war from ramayana and the vedas dr.
The Epic Riddle Of Dating Ramayana, Mahabharata
Ramayana Scientific Dating Wrong? Thus a shift of 10 story has occured since the Ramayanic Era. Authenticity has a ramayana of years per nakshatra.
Then Arjuna successfully resisted Karna’s weapons with his own and also inflicted casualties upon the Kaurava ramayana. The sun soon wrote and with date.
He freshly evaluated astronomy observations of Mahabharata text, which led to validation of BCE as the year of Mahabharata War while falsifying more than alternate claims. Nilesh researches in astronomy, archeology, anthropology, quantum mechanics, economics, naturopathy, ancient narratives and philosophy. Nilesh resides in Atlanta, USA. Here is the refined transcript of the talk delivered by Nilesh.
While he starts with basic queries, he stresses on the AV observation and evidence in Mahabharata and Ramayana and conclusively answers the age of the two ancient Hindu texts. Nilesh Nilkanth Oak:. You formulate your question.